Some thoughts on the Heatley trade.

I’m a bit late to the party, perhaps, but some thoughts on the Heatley trade.

My initial reaction was — and it somewhat surprised me — that since Marleau wasn’t part of the trade, that maybe it was okay. Heatley still has to prove to me he’s bringing the right attitude, but honestly, Doug Wilson’s a much better judge of that than I am, and I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt until proven otherwise. And honestly? It fits in line with something I said back in 2008, which Puck Daddy was nice enough to dredge up for me and point to.

My bottom line is that I’m happier because the trade didn’t involve Marleau, but I still need to see Heatley bring the right attitude and the right game, and if he does, then  this is a great trade. if he doesn’t — Wilson will have to deal with it.

I’m not unhappy at seeing Michalek and Cheechoo go. Well, I’ll miss them because I enjoyed watching them play, especially Cheechoo, but I always felt Michalek had a “next step” he never figured out how to use consistently, and I think we saw the best of Cheechoo and he had no real upside. With any luck, new teams and fresh starts will help them, but they weren’t going to get better in San jose.

One question brought up to me, since I’d mentioned Larionov and his demanding his way off the team — why do I give Larionov a pass on that and not Heatley?

I had to think about that one a bit, and here’s why: Larionov had a strong track record as a player for his ethics and his committment. he was also a winner with multiple organizations. Because of that when he speaks up about something taht’s wrong — and time really proved him right in San Jose — you listen.

Heatley doesn’t have that. Heatley’s proven that in the NHL, he can score lots of goals, but he’s never proven himself as a winner. he’s also indicated through his actions in Ottawa that when he doesn’t get his way, he pouts and quits. He now has to prove himself NOT to be a quitter — and only time will tell about that. Right now, though, he doesn’t have that track record to stand on, and his actiosn the last few months put him in a negative light to many of us. He has to prove that wrong. And I’m willing to let him, but he doesn’t get a free ride, because he hasn’t earned one yet.

Related posts:

1. Looking at the Dany Heatley trade Now that we’re in November, I wanted to take...
2. Should the Sharks break up the top line of Thornton and Heatley? That’s the question I’ve asked myself after watching the...
3. so, what about the Joe Thornton trade? I was tied up moving plaidworks to the new...
4. Sharks lose to Dallas — again; and we’re heading towards the trade deadline, so let’s go start some rumors… Sharkspage – San Jose Sharks, Hockey, NHL sports blog:...
5. a quick note on the sharks at the trade deadline… woo-hoo! I like the deals, all three of them....