Of 3G iPads and MiFis

Fraser Speirs – Blog – Of 3G iPads and MiFis:

Fraser goes on to discuss the pros and cons of the Wifi vs. 3G iPads and describes nicely a major reason why I haven’t bought an iPad yet.

Not for lack of interest; the iPad sits in a niche I’d really like to fill. I love the idea of being able to sit down on the couch and “consume content”, get the keyboard out of the way and get back to the “good old days” style model that a paper book brought, only with all of the new content types the internet brings you. That and being able to sit down and play games on the same device? I’ve found it very re-energizing (sorry, you hard core geeks out there) to unplug for a while in the evenings — just get away from the laptop, away from email and keyboards and geeking and all that stuff; just sit on the couch with laurie and either watch TV or “do something” like read or browse my RSS feeds or play sudoku or fire up the XBOX. Or just hang out with Laurie and talk through things.

I currently tend to do that with the Palm Pre, but it’s not really the right form factor. I don’t want to haul out the laptop, it’s also not the right form factor for what I want to do, and if it’s busy crunching photos or doing “real work”, it’s not necessarily available. So there’s a need for a middle ground, one with a larger screen than the mobile phone (where the primary use case is “must fit in pocket and do stuff”) but without all of the extra stuff that comes with a laptop, like the keyboard.

And the iPad fits that wonderfully. Except…

The whole connectivity thing isn’t right for me yet. Wifi is fine here at home, but on the road? I don’t do a lot of travelling, but I see myself doing more photo tripping in the future, and probably starting to do some conference trips as well, so whatever solution I get I have to understand how connectivity is going to work on the road, where “on the road” doesn’t imply “depend on hotel wifi and Starbucks”. But I’m honestly also trying to keep my gadget life as simple as possible, so I don’t want to pick up something like a Mifi (and the Mifi monthly service charge!) just for  few days a year of need. Not cost effective.

Neither is the 3G iPad — because there’s no tethering option. If the 3G iPad tethered so I could use it to connect in my other internet-enabled devices as needed, it’d be a no brainer and I’d do it in a second. But it doesn’t. That means if I’m on the road and would need to upload photos from the laptop (or, gasp, vpn in to work on an emergency) I’m still depending on hotel wifi and/or Starbucks. That’s a fail for me — I need an “on the road” networking solution, not an iPad that connect to the network.

Or I need some other tethering solution that supports the iPad — without adding in a new geek toy (and monthly service charge!) to do it. Unfortunately, my two cell phones (geek eye roll. sigh.) are my Pre on Sprint, and my (really old, really, really old) iPhone on AT&T. Neither carrier supports tethering on those devices.

So basically, I don’t like any of my options, and I just haven’t decided to jump in anyway; if I did, I’d jump in with a Wifi unit…. Which I probably will, but not until after I upgrade my aging, 4 year old laptop… I’m staying on the sidelines for now, waiting to see how various things play out.

My first hope is tethering will come to AT&T; WWDC is coming, iPhone 4.0 is coming, the tethering rumors have swirled again, and we’ll have to see. If they announce tethering for iPhone, I’m expecting we might also see it for the AT&T Pre Plus; if that happens, I can dump my Sprint phone, get a PrePlus upgrade on AT&T and turn on tethering and life is good (yes, I don’t mind paying a bit more for tethering on a phone, I do mind paying for another entire contract for another device for tethering)

It’s possible AT&T might do tethering on the iPhone and not push it out onto the PrePlus. If they do, I’ll make rude noises about their familial heritage and have to decide if I want to upgrade my AT&T contract to the new (currently rumored) iPhone and keep two cell phones (My preference is to simplify and get back to one phone on one carrier; right now AT&T is telling me to upgrade my contract to the pre is $249, so it’s actually cheaper to keep the two phones right now barring a real reason to upgrade)

If that doesn’t happen, Clear is coming to silicon valley around the end of the year. That’s what I’m currently looking at as an option to upgrade the home DSL network. they have a nice bundle that includes a home network connection and a mobile USB dongle that does uncapped 4G and falls back to a 3G connection (with a 5 gig/mo cap) if you’re out of 4G territory. There are currently some rumors floating that they’re going to refocus from Wimax to LTE, but either way, getting a home internet connection and a mobile dongle for $55/month is a good deal — once it rolls out. Assuming it works, of course. So I’m watching and willing to wait and trying to avoid things with contract terms until that hits the floor. And once it does, I’m hoping it pushes other carriers to reprice as well…

Smartphones really started pushing us into the world of ubiquitous computing; my pocket is always online, and that changes what data I keep and how I interact with it. iPad pushes that to the next level and really starts showing off online content as a commodity to be consumed; for the first time, online “stuff” is really for anyone, not just the geeky. That trend is going to continue, but the infrastructure is in transition to properly support that, and all of the pieces are just not quite there yet. And I’m just happy to be patient and give them all a chance to settle out rather than rush in and pay a few hundred bucks (and a two year contract) for something that six months from now I’ll have a much better (and cheaper) solution for… Sometimes, you dn’t have to be in a hurry.

You might also want to read:

1. I have committed iPad. It’s official. I have committed iPad. I noticed last night that one of the local Best Buy’s had them in stock, so I decided it...
2. Of 3G iPads and MiFis Of 3G iPads and MiFis | Chuqui 3.0: My first hope is tethering will come to AT&T; WWDC is coming, iPhone 4.0 is coming, the tethering...
3. MacBook 3G: Ringer or Red Herring? MacBook 3G: Ringer or Red Herring? | TheAppleBlog: So is this a logical “next move” by Cupertino, as Mawston suggests? If Apple were actually in...