Notes from the Commish: My Take on Lucic and Ryan

barfy.jpg

Welcome to the latest ruling in “Notes from the Commish” where I as the Commish of the NHL (in my universe) and my Vice President of Disclipine Barfy will pontificate upon the state of the game .

KuklasKorner : Hockey:

69.4 Contact Outside the Goal Crease – If an attacking player initiates any contact with a goalkeeper, other than incidental contact, while the goalkeeper is outside his goal crease, and a goal is scored, the goal will be disallowed.

 

A goalkeeper is not “fair game” just because he is outside the goal crease. The appropriate penalty should be assessed in every case where an attacking player makes unnecessary contact with the goalkeeper. However, incidental contact will be permitted when the goalkeeper is in the act of playing the puck outside his goal crease provided the attacking player has made a reasonable effort to avoid such unnecessary contact.

 

I was watching the game when Lucic rolled through Ryan and started the kerfluffle.

Now, of course, Buffalo is demanding Lucic get suspended.

Regier is adamant Lucic should be suspended for the hit. Lucic will have a hearing today at 1 p.m. to discuss the first-period play in which Miller was knocked to the ice and his helmet was knocked off.

 

I sympathize with Buffalo. It sucks that he got injured in the play. My take on it is simple. Watching Lucic, it seemed to me he saw he was coming down on Ryan and decided “oh, heck, I’ll take the two minutes”. and did.

Honestly? I don’t blame him.  To some degree,  blame Ryan for being so sure there was going to be no contact that he was completely unready for the contact when it came. Yes, Goalies are “not fair game”, but that was a classic situation where the two players both had a legitimate reason to fight for the puck, only Ryan was so sure he was “safe” he never thought that Lucic would actually challenge him. He did, and Ryan went down and went bang.

I’m sorry, but my view is that this was caused because goalies have decided they are TOO privileged, not that they need to be protected more. Ryan should have been more aware of the chance of contact, and if he was worried about it, either not been so aggressive about going after that puck, or been ready for it. I think Lucic deserved two minutes for the hit, but I don’t think the hit was anything significant, nor do I think he deserves a suspension. I think goalies have to get over thinking that nobody can touch them at all, and have some responsibility for contact, even if we don’t go back to the “if you’re out of the crease, you’re fair game” concept.

Ryan seemed to believe that because he had some control of the puck that Lucic would peel off and not touch him at all. I find that concept both naive and a negative one for the sport overall. I’ve seen goalies chase out after a puck to break up a breakaway by submarining the oncoming player out beyond the face-off dots and haven’t heard anyone call to suspend the goalie for that, so honestly, what’s good for the goose is good for the gander.

My hint to goalies: if you’re going to wander out away from the blue paint, expect some contact. Ryan didn’t, and when it came, he wasn’t ready. In this case, Lucic clearly made a decision to go for the hit, but think about it: if Lucic instead didn’t see Ryan and hit him inadvertently, Ryan would still be concussed. And that’s why this isn’t a case for “more protection for the goalies” or “suspend Lucic until he rots”, it’s instead time for goalies to stop thinking nobody is allowed to touch them, “fair game” or not, and get back to a mentality where they realize contact is going to happen, and either not be so aggressive thinking this special protection will save them from their actions, or be ready for the consequences and take the hit.

Sorry, Buffalo, but this is more your goalie’s fault than Lucic’s.

(and updated — the nhl agrees with me on no suspension, which came out after I wrote this, but before it was posted)

Today’s Shared Links for November 14, 2011

Today’s Shared Links for November 13, 2011

Today’s Shared Links for November 12, 2011

Today’s Shared Links for November 11, 2011

Today’s Shared Links for November 10, 2011

Today’s Shared Links for November 9, 2011

Publishing to Smugmug, a geek’s view (Part 5)

Welcome to the final piece in this series on geeking lightroom and Smugmug.

Check out the entire series:

  • In part 1, we get lightroom set up to use the publishing model and connect it to smugmug in a way that updates can be synced over, meaning when you make changes later, they can be sent to smugmug without having to manually find and update every image by hand.
  • With part 2, we dove into Smugmug smart galleries and learned how to set up your Smugmug site so that it would automatically put images into galleries based on your keywords and metadata.
  • Part 3 looks at a few techniques for using Smart Collections in Lightroom to help you automate some of your keyword tasks and do sanity checking that your keywords and metadata are doing what you want them to.
  • In Part 4, I show you the details on some of the galleries I’ve set up and how to use them on your site.
  • In Part 5, I talk about ways to use smugmug and ways I’d like to see the site improved.

To close this series out, I wanted to talk a bit about Smugmug smart galleries and ways I’d like to see them improved.

In practice, the implementation of Smart Galleries is pretty good. Because you can chain smart galleries together and create a gallery with interim results to use to create a final gallery, there’s very little you will be unable to do if you’re willing to think through building your selections and exclusions.

I ran into one bug which is fairly easy to work around: that a smart gallery with multiple EXCLUDE selectors doesn’t seem to work right. it almost looks to me like the 2nd EXCLUDE causes the system to throw all of the exclude clauses out. Other than that, the system worked as I expected it to.

It would be nice to see the size limits (1000 images for a smart gallery, 5000 for real galleries) increased, but to be honest, I can’t honestly say I think it’s a significant limitation. In practice, I only ran into this first limit twice, both for galleries building interim selections, and in both cases, it was easy to find an alternative way to solve the problem.  3,000 and 10,000 would work for me for years. 1,000 and 5,000 work fine for me as long as I remember to think about them.

I would like to see more than five selectors on a smart gallery (ten?). It would reduce the need to create interim result galleries. I would also like to see smart gallery selectors get smarter and allow a more flexible logic, especially mixing AND and OR logic (“include (fred AND jane) or (jerry and elvis)”). There’s a tradeoff here: allowing more complex logic is going to create more opportunities for people to get themselves into situations they don’t understand why it’s not working.

I would like to see some new ways to do selections, such as “all images in any gallery in the ‘birds’ section”. Alternatively, I would love to be able to create a smart gallery of all images in “this gallery” that are not shown in any smart gallery (the “which images are missing” gallery). One place I had to think through doing things was my mammals: there’s no easy way to say “all mammals, except “these” and “these” and these”) because of the 2-exclusion clause bug, and then soon after, the 5 rule limit.  ended up solving it by re-arranging my keyword nesting in Lightroom, but that means my sea otters and sea lions aren’t listed as mammals. It’s a minor thing, but it annoys me a bit, because I’m kinda picky at times.

This all starts looking like a relational database schema after a while, and I have to sometimes resist the urge to over-normalize the design. But if you think about it, smart galleries look a lot like views, and the selection criteria start looking like triggers.

I’ve noted a couple of things that people ought to be aware of before they start doing this.

First, all of your stats will show up as being tied to the real gallery, so you won’t be able to see analytics on which smart gallery the image was actually seen in. If you want that kind of data, you’re going to be unhappy, because there’s no way to get it. For me, this is fine. If that kind of detail on how people are finding images is important to you, this strategy won’t work.

Second, I have noticed a few cases where updating the galleries locked up or broke the site for short periods of time. It looks like while a smart gallery is being updated by the hidden background processes there are some locks put in place or the data is inconsistent. These inconsistencies tend to be very short lived, but they are visible to the end user. This implies that if you’re doing significant updates that affect many of your galleries, you might want to split them up into smaller chunks, or time them for when things are quiet (like start the publishing push before going to bed). If absolute 100% “my site is never funky” is a requirement, this strategy might not work for you. In all cases where I did see this, it seemed to involve significant sets of updates (> 100 images being pushed that rippled across the galleries) where it seemed like the gallery update daemon was trying to update the galleries while a previous run was still updating them. And in all cases, the glitches fixed themselves and went away within a few minutes of the publishing push finishing. And on the vast majority of publishing pushes (95% of them) I never saw a thing, so this is a minor case at best.

Overall, when I started this, I wasn’t sure if Smugmug’s smart galleries would hold up to what I was trying to do. I found they handled the abuse I threw at them just fine. Now that I have this up and running, it’s my greatest hope I won’t need to re-think how I publish things for at least 3-5 years; and rearranging the furniture using this strategy is easy and mostly painless. It takes a little bit of work to get set up; it saves a lot of work over time. I can live with that kind of investment.

 

Page 30 of 222« First...1020...27282930313233...4050607080...Last »